• Suffering poor health? Too bad for you

    by  • March 7, 2013 • Articles, Comment • 2 Comments

    A rather disturbing report on Wellington’s health services shows that central government policies have led directly to people already in poor health getting even lower priority.

    ‘From Great to Good’, by professor Don Matheson, explains how – under pressure from central government targets – the Capital Coast District Health Board (C&CDHB) has increased spending on hospitals relative to GP and other basic health services.

    The report, based on official information act requests, says that the health system already gives less to those at the bottom (despite what the public might think), even though they need more support.

    Treasury figures show that an upper middle class household receives on average almost $11,000 of health services a year, whereas the households with the lowest income receive on average $6,000 of health services – despite their greater need.

    The latest New Zealand Health Survey shows that one million New Zealanders had “unmet need” for primary health care in the last year – and this is worst among Maori, Pacific and low income groups.

    Our health system is less equitable – that is, it does little to help those most in need – compared with those of Australia, Canada, Germany, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom. Only the USA has a more unfair health system.

    The sad thing is that before 2008, Wellington’s health board was making progress in narrowing these health inequalities and helping those on the bottom. But since then, the report finds, the board has become focussed on meeting centrally imposed hospital targets.

    While getting more operations done is important, it shouldn’t have come at the expense of funding frontline GP, maternity and other services – which have been cut by hundreds of thousands of dollars, and which most affect low-income households.

    As the report puts it: “C&CDHB’s direction … decreased in scope and became increasingly focused on the Minister of Health’s targets.

    “This narrowing of focus crowded out the previous focus the Board had on equity for the population that it serves. While previously it had led performance in addressing equity, it is now actively disinvesting in the providers that helped secure that leadership position … while at the same time push[ing] costs onto patients who could least afford to pay.”

    Max Rashbrooke


    Max is an author, academic and journalist working in Wellington, New Zealand, where he writes about politics, finance and social issues. Sign up to Max's mailing list.

    2 Responses to Suffering poor health? Too bad for you

    1. Debbie Leyland
      April 18, 2013 at 1:53 am

      It is really good that this paper and the crisis we have in our health system.

      The WCC conducted a quality of life survey which makes grim reading. Section 4 of this survey looks at health.
      You can access this survey on


      Please visit our website for more information on ucannz.org.nz
      Many thanks
      Debbie Leyland

    2. Pingback: Inequality at Writers Festival | UCAN NZ

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *